|
The
record regarding Head Start and community-based programs reveals
that in Newark and Paterson
and West New York, existing Head Start and other community-
based organizations appear quite willing to form a part of the
districts' plan to provide early
childhood education for all eligible children. In the case of
Head Start, the DOE acknowledges
the failure to reach a final statewide accord with Head Start,
but has not offered any explanation
why it could not do so. If the reason was that the non-Abbott-
compliant Head Start programs
were seeking exorbitant and unnecessary amounts of
per-pupil assistance to supplement federal funds and the Department
became convinced that these
programs were attempting to gouge the districts and the State,
then certifications and other
documentary evidence in support of these contentions
should have been produced. It is true that, as asserted in the
Department's brief, to the extent
that a Head Start agency cannot maintain Abbott standards at the
offered contract rate, the Department
need not enter into a contract with that agency. However,
that presumes that the rate offered to the Head Start agency was
a fair and appropriate rate
based upon a reasonable assessment of the actual needs of the
program and of the students
it would serve. More broadly, the several allegations
that the Department imposed
a $4,500 per-pupil rate should have evoked more than a simple
denial in the Department's brief
that the DOE did not use an estimated amount per child. (See
further discussion regarding this subject in the Funding section
below.)At oral
argument, co-counsel for the DOE noted that, while aware that
negotiations had occurred with
the Head Start programs, they could not say what actually happened.
Of course, except to the extent
that they might have been actual participants in the
negotiations (they were not), the statements of counsel would
not be evidential, but at least
might have offered some insight into what happened and why no
accord was reached. The Attorney
General in fact conceded at oral argument that the record is
barren of any evidence as to how the DOE determined the actual
needs of the Head Start programs
involved, including those of their students. Even more, regarding
the contracts with community-based
programs addressed in the West, Johnson, Morris-
Yamba and Dickey certifications, how the districts decided upon
the actual assistance
|